Best in Middletown, NY​

Family Farm Ice Cream

At Family Farm Ice Cream, we bring the warmth of the farm to your table with our delicious homemade ice cream. Crafted in small batches using the finest ingredients, every scoop is a celebration of rich flavors and creamy goodness. Whether you’re craving classic favorites or adventurous seasonal creations, we promise a taste of happiness in every bite!

The Ice Cream Shop.​

Nestled in the heart of Middletown, Family Farm Ice Cream is a celebration of tradition and flavor. Each batch of our homemade ice cream is lovingly crafted, from the finest ingredients to the creamy, rich textures that make every scoop unforgettable. Whether you’re stopping by for a sweet treat, indulging in your favorite classic flavors, or discovering new seasonal creations, our ice cream is more than just dessert—it’s a heartfelt story of passion, community, and the joy of sharing simple pleasures.

Delicious homemade chocolate ice cream in a tray with a colorful scoop, garnished with cacao nibs.
banana, split, ice cream

Featured Flavors

Made Fresh!

Creamery Hours​

Monday to Wednesday: Closed
Thursday: 3PM – 8PM
Friday: 12PM – 9PM
Saturday: 12PM – 9PM
Sunday: 12PM – 8PM

They All Love Our Ice Cream!​

Posted on Yelp Yelp
Kasia C. profile picture
Kasia C.
Yelp star 1Yelp star 2Yelp star 3Yelp star 4Yelp star 5Verified
Driving back home from Monticello with the kids - we wanted to stop for ice cream on the way & this place came up. We got them right before closing at 9pm. There are endless choices but the kids went with rainbow vanilla, I got turtles, amaretto almond & dark chocolate raspberry truffles and my husband got a whole banana split. Ice cream was wonderful - there are places to sit outside at picnic tables but unfortunately no bathrooms anywhere.
Posted on Yelp Yelp
John B. profile picture
John B.
Yelp star 1Yelp star 2Yelp star 3Yelp star 4Yelp star 5Verified
First cream of the year. Big scoops with lots of flavors. Pleasant service. Busy but not crazy. Service is quick but and not rushed. Samples are available to help you decide We will go back again.
Posted on Yelp Yelp
Peter M. profile picture
Peter M.
Yelp star 1Yelp star 2Yelp star 3Yelp star 4Yelp star 5Verified
Hersey ice cream. Tons of flavors. Helpful staff. Great ambience as a typical ice cream parlor. We'll worth the trip. Soft serve too. Tables and chairs inside and out.
Posted on Yelp Yelp
Ray R. profile picture
Ray R.
Yelp star 1Yelp star 2Yelp star 3Yelp star 4Yelp star 5Verified
Great ice cream spot with an awesome staff!! My wife loves the raspberry chocolate ice cream they have there. Prices are pretty good too.
Posted on Yelp Yelp
Kyle V. profile picture
Kyle V.
Yelp star 1Yelp star 2Yelp star 3Yelp star 4Yelp star 5Verified
This fantastic ice cream shop is a must stop for any tourist visiting Legoland or any other surrounding area attraction; it's worth the drive. Family Farm offers numerous flavors of delicious ice cream and sundae topping options. The staff is friendly and accommodating. Whenever I'm in Goshen, I make the trip to Middletown solely to enjoy Family Farm Ice Cream.
Posted on Yelp Yelp
Karl L. profile picture
Karl L.
Yelp star 1Yelp star 2Yelp star 3Yelp star 4Yelp star 5Verified
Great freindly place for all ages ...the ice cream is delicious..the service with a smile top shelf...
Posted on Yelp Yelp
Tanya B. profile picture
Tanya B.
Yelp star 1Yelp star 2Yelp star 3Yelp star 4Yelp star 5Verified
Great place. Delicious ice cream, lots of fun flavor options and super nice owner. Nice find that will fulfill an ice cream craving!
Posted on Yelp Yelp
Yara C. profile picture
Yara C.
Yelp star 1Yelp star 2Yelp star 3Yelp star 4Yelp star 5Verified
Really friendly to us even though we showed up 5 minutes before closing! They have a nice selection of flavors that f Hershey Ice Cream and are super affordable.
Posted on Yelp Yelp
Aig E. profile picture
Aig E.
Yelp star 1Yelp star 2Yelp star 3Yelp star 4Yelp star 5Verified
Very generous! Medium size comes with 3 large scoops! And the cuppichino ice cream tastes awesome!
Posted on Yelp Yelp
LAKENDA G. profile picture
LAKENDA G.
Yelp star 1Yelp star 2Yelp star 3Yelp star 4Yelp star 5Verified
Great customer service and ice cream. They ran out of strawberry ice, the owner went out of his way to make me a strawberry sundae with fresh strawberries
Scroll to Top